Paulie Gee's Logan Square

Paulie Gee's is a walk-in-only wood-fired pizza spot right on Milwaukee Ave in Logan Square. No reservations accepted — first come, first served, and your whole party must be present to be seated (which fits perfectly with P&T's confirmation model). Pizzas around $17 make it one of the most affordable and fun date spots in the neighborhood. Casual, lively, and shareable — pizza is inherently a great first date food. Weekend lunch hours open up daytime date options too.